https://www.amazon.com/dp/B09RGMCQ4C
I was a very pious child, but there was one thing that had always made me doubt the existence of God: his schizophrenia. The God of the Old Testament is very much the opposite of the God of the New Testament, at least as far as his values are concerned:
If we plot those values onto Solomon Schwartz’s circle of basic values with my evolved types we find something interesting:
The God of the Old Testament is located firmly in farmer space, termed “conservation” by Schwarz, whereas the God of the New Testament is firmly located in hunter-gatherer space, mostly in gatherer space, though, termed “self-transcendence” by Schwarz.
This would account perfectly for the kind of schizophrenia we observe in God. In fact, if we trace back the evolution of the God meme further into the past, we find that there was a chasm between Abraham’s God and Moses’ God (a god of many rules), that reflects a transition from pastoralism to farming by the “Chosen People”.
The earliest parts of the Bible have very strong indications of an origin of the God meme in pastoralism: a sky god (similarly to the Inde-European gods Zeus, Jupiter, Odin and Dyaus Pitar - pastoralists are even more dependent on rain than farmers), the Ark was kept in a tent, and last but not least god preferred Able, the herder over his brother Cain, the farmer. The God of the Judeo-Christian tradition, therefore, shows elements of three different temperaments, starting with herders, modified by farmers and finally reformed by a gatherer type (Jesus Christ).
The following is a passage from the above book that discusses pastoralist influences on the God meme.
The Patriarchs: Polytheist Pastoralists
Timeline: ~1.800 BC
Nahor lived nine and twenty years, and begat Terah: And Nahor lived after he begat Terah an hundred and nineteen years, and begat sons and daughters. And Terah lived seventy years, and begat Abram, Nahor, and Haran. [...]
People familiar with the bible know that this “begat” thing goes on tediously for a long time. When I was an altar boy I was always struck by the utter uselessness of the information (they could really have cut this short, by saying that Abraham was a distant descendant of Shem and Noah). Well, I have to admit, I was wrong. There was a point in remembering all those ancestors, as I wrote above. If you were lucky you could inherit a fortune from some distant childless uncle in America, er… sorry, in Ur. There is nothing wrong in venerating your loved ones who are deceased, but that is only part of the story of ancestor worship. Your ancestors bestowed wealth and status upon you.
This system is known as patrilineality and it is frequent among semi-nomadic pastoralists and occasionally also among semi-nomadic horticulturalists.
Shugri Said Salh writes in her autobiographical book The Last Nomad: Coming of Age in the Somali Desert (2021):
As they moved about the terrain, herding camels and other livestock long distances to find water, the nomads came into contact with each other, so they not only knew the land but knew where other tribes were currently located. To access this information, my mother had to give the “nomadic password,” which was her full name and the name of her subclans. [...] Somali children are taught to memorize the full name of each of their father’s ancestors as far as ten to twenty generations back or more. You might see a little girl, only four or five years old, proudly reciting the names of her forefathers all the way back to the original member of the four clans.
Voilà, there you have got it. It’s not unlikely that among Abraham’s descendants every child could recite his name in a long line of patrilineal ancestors.
It’s not hard to see that ancestor worship gave rise to a belief in the afterlife, with distant ancestors assuming divine status once enough time has passed so that nobody can prove the opposite.
Abraham’s god was just that, Abraham’s ancestral god. Or rather the god of his tribe, who had to compete with other gods from neighbouring tribes. The Abrahamic religion is not a monotheistic one.
Modern research suggests that the religion of Abraham and his fellow Hebrews was not, strictly speaking, monotheistic at all, but “monolatrous.” In other words, during Abraham’s time and for many centuries afterward, the ancient Hebrews worshipped not a God whom they held to be the sole deity in existence, but simply one god among many, a god whom they conceived of as being more powerful than the jostling plethora of lesser gods worshipped by other peoples, but who nonetheless shared the stage with them. This essentially polytheistic outlook accords with the frequent mention of other gods in the Hebrew Bible. (source)
In Mesopotamia Abraham's family worshipped “other gods.” In Canaan they adopted the name of the Canaanites' supreme god, El, for a god Abraham experienced as uniquely transcendent and personal, to whom he entrusted himself and his family, worshipping that god exclusively as “God Most High.” (source)
We can see the transition from ancestry worship to high, albeit not yet monotheistic, go here. The religion of Abraham's religion must have been very similar to what the pastoralist Dinka practice:
The majority of Dinka practice traditional religions whose central theme is the worship of a high god through the totem, ancestral spirits, and a number of deities. The high god is called Nhiali and he is the source of sustenance. (source)
Abraham’s god is not yet the God of many rules he would later become. Hunter-gatherers and pastoralists are egalitarian and do not like authoritarian, hierarchical governance. However, in contrast to hunter-gatherers pastoralists consider themselves superior to other tribes, a political orientation called social dominance hierarchy (SDO).
It’s therefore no surprise that Abrahm’s religion is not a universalist religion but one for the chosen people.
“I will make you into a great nation, and I will bless you;
I will make your name great, and you will be a blessing.
I will bless those who bless you, and whoever curses you I will curse;
and all peoples on earth will be blessed through you.” (Genesis 12:2-3)
On that day the Lord made a covenant with Abram and said, "To your descendants I give this land, from the Wadi of Egypt to the great river, the Euphrates— the land of the Kenites, Kenizzites, Kadmonites, Hittites, Perizzites, Rephaites, Amorites, Canaanites, Girgashites and Jebusites."
This elitist ideology may have helped spread the God meme among herder tribes. We know that Abraham was the leader of a pastoralist tribe not only because he offered God a lamb instead of his son, but because of numerous clues in the bible. One is the concept of a sky god.
"That the Lord, He is God in heaven above and upon the earth beneath" (Deut. 4.39)
It has been suggested several times that sky gods are a typical pastoralist phenomenon that pastoralists bestowed later upon the farming peoples they conquered. We are familiar with sky gods from the Indo-European cultures derived from the pastoralist Yamnya: Zeus in Greek mythology and Odin in Norse mythology.
In time the pastoralists, even more than farmers, looked increasingly for deliverance to the sky and the mountains, where storms were engendered, living as they did in marginal habitats, made more so by overgrazing by their cattle, where rain was scarce and bestowed by arbitrary gods.The grasses greened quickly after showers and were just as quickly eaten, forcing the livestock and their owners to move on.
Of course, pastoralists and foragers often share similar conditions. However, Abraham’s god had come a long way from forager religion. Mobility, leisure, security, even the opportunity to go on gathering from the wilderness were present in pastoralism. But the resemblance between nomadic foragers and semi-nomadic pastoralists is superficial. The warrior theme, the singular sky god, the myth of the wandering hero, the practice of sacrifice, the tilt of gender relationships, and the economy of domestic animals—all part of the pastoralist culture—were the antithesis of the hunter-gatherer world.
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B09RGMCQ4C
Comments
Post a Comment